GCC COMPETITION
Table of Judging Criteria
|
Total marks out of 5/criteria. Judges can award scores of 1,2,3,4,5 |
Descriptor for 1 mark |
Descriptor for 3 marks |
Descriptor for 5 marks |
|
Response to theme |
Limited alignment of the content with the SDGs. The explanation of why the entrant chose the topic and why it is important to them is limited and not well articulated. |
Clear and explicit alignment with one or more of the SDGs. The explanation of why the entrant chose the topic and why it is important to them is provided but may lack depth and breadth of insight and may not articulate how the work relates to the entrant’s future role as a healthcare professional |
Clear and explicit alignment with one or more of the SDGs and the wellbeing of people, cultures and the planet is reflected throughout all aspects of the creative piece. The explanation of why the entrant chose the topic and why it is important to them shows depth and breadth of insight. The entrant considers a range of evidence sources and perspectives and considers their future role as a healthcare professional.
|
|
Creativity |
The creative work demonstrates some craft and aesthetic quality.
|
The creative work is well crafted* and has aesthetic quality and character. The work demonstrates limited originality e.g., you may have seen something similar before. |
The artwork is well crafted* and has outstanding aesthetic quality and character. The way in which materials are chosen and used is innovative, original and enhances the quality of the submission.
|
|
Impact |
The work is understood by the judges but does not prompt them to pause and reflect |
The work is understood by the judges and stimulates them to engage and reflect upon the perspectives that it presents. |
The work is understood and stimulates continued engagement and refection. The work brings new or different perspectives on the chosen topic and competition theme. The artwork leaves a lasting impression.. |
|
Score & comment to help the judge choose between the entries that are being put forward to the next round of judging. |
Total score:
Comments: |
*By craft we mean the structure, skill and technicality of the work. We will not be considering aspects of work that relies upon an individual’s access to equipment, e.g., we would not judge the sound or visual quality of a recording.